There is a second thesis concerning simultaneity deriving from special relativity, which we have barely discussed so far. If you have any comments or questions on these lecture notes, please email them to takeuchiatvtdotedu. Pdf are presentism and special theory of relativity. Pdf the problem with the relativity of simultaneity researchgate. What we actually mean here is that the concept of simultaneity will depend on which frame you are in. While teaching special relativity the physics professor is in the same position as a parent who helps his little child solving a math problem. B deflection angle is the ratio of the transverse velocity to the forward speed. New relativistic paradoxes and open questions smarandache. This resource helpsheet for special relativity covers the following concepts for a noncalculus course. Einsteins idea is to consider two lightnings, simultaneously falling at the trains extremities. In section 2, i illustrate a presentist model cone model, cm, which mark hinchliff 2000 presents as compatible with a relativistic setting. The course will start with a selfcontained introduction to special relativity and then proceed to the more general setting of lorentzian manifolds.
Consequences of special relativity boundless physics. Basically, special relativity can be stated as the invariance of any spacetime interval that is the 4d distance between any two events when viewed from any inertial reference frame. The most familiar example is the length of a moving body, since that length is given by the distance between the objects endpoint at the same moment in time. We expect the laws of inertial physics to be the same in all inertial frames, but we also expect the speed of light to be globally constant. Signal sent out from b at t 0 is described in s by arrival at a and c given by intersections 1, 1. Why special relativity is a problem for the atheory the. Now we need to develop the method of making time and space measurements according to special relativity. From the doxerl affair to the miracle year, and has had over 30,000 students worldwide enroll in his online course on the special theory of relativity this course. Einsteins special relativity upended our understanding of space, time and energy. Resolve using rates of signal emission and reception. If not, the presentist is at least free to grapple with the other implications of. Principle of relativity a229004 5 a229004 principle of relativity 9 special theory of relativity postulates. Relativity and unveil the fascinating properties of black holes, one of the most celebrated predictions of mathematical physics. An introduction to the special theory of relativity.
Postulates of the special theory of relativity simultaneity time dilation and the twin paradox length contraction fourdimensional spacetime relativistic momentum and mass the ultimate speed e mc 2. But the relativity of simultaneity and the consequent relativity of time ordering is, while surprising, not exactly paradoxical. Block universe from special relativity oxford scholarship. Why special relativity is a problem for the atheory. Relativity of simultaneity now suppose a, and at rest in s which is moving at speed v along xaxis. Einsteins rethinking resulted in the special theory of relativity that states that the velocity dependence of simultaneity is a consequence of the relativity of space and time. Identify exactly what needs to be determined in the problem identify the unk. Conceptual problems on introductory special relativity shovan dutta cornell university shovan dutta problems on relativity.
Go to for 20% off a premium subscription to brilliant. Using them correctly we can solve all the problems encountered in. There is no reference frame in which light can appear to be at rest. Pdf relativity claims that the simultaneity between two or more observers, each traveling in different inertial reference frames irfs is such that. It is the thesis of the conventionality of simultaneity.
Events which are simultaneous in one reference frame will not be simultaneous in a second inertial reference frame moving relative to the first frame. In other words no experiment has allowed to observe the relativity of simultaneity. There is no such thing as simultaneity of distant events. But if everything is just here now, then every event is just happening now. If the special theory truly entails relativity of simultaneity, then it is in direct conflict with presentism. Intuitively, it seems that the time for a process, such as the elapsed time for a foot race figure \\pageindex1\, should be the same for all observers. This is a simple consequence of the fact that the speed of. In albert einsteins original treatment, the theory is based on two postulates the laws of physics are invariant that is, identical in all inertial frames of reference that is, frames of reference with no acceleration. The relativity of simultaneity events which are simultaneous in one reference frame will.
Much of the material is at a level suitable for high school students who have had advanced placement in physics and mathematics. Thought experiments for the relativity of simultaneity 15 pts in the rst lecture we discussed thought experiments that can be used to derive the three kinematic consequences of special relativity. Pdf the problem with the relativity of simultaneity. Synthese library monographs on epistemology, logic, methodology, philosophy of science, sociology of science and of knowledge, and on the mathematical methods of social and behavioral.
Principle of relativity physical laws are the same in all inertial reference frames. The relativity of simultaneity is the concept that simultaneity whether two events occur at the same timeis not absolute, but depends on the. Lecture 3 and 4 relativity of simultaneity lorentzeinstein. Knowing algebra the parent could solve the problem in two lines, but he may have serious problems explaining it in simple but insightful terms that are comprehensible for the child. While the ideas are subtle, they only require high school algebra, so join this mathbased introduction with acclaimed physicist and author, brian greene. The relativity of simultaneity permeates special relativity. The laws of physics are the same everywhere no matter what the speed of the observer. Mass and energy relativistic addition of velocities the impact of special relativity basic problems. New ideas are presented on special relativity and the problem of space and a mechanism for gravity is suggested. Articles in pers are expected to focus on these issues as well, but to pay more. Simultaneity and synchronization by rods in relativity as. He realized that the reckoning of simultaneity depended on the velocity of the observer.
In physics, the special theory of relativity, or special relativity for short, is a scientific theory regarding the relationship between space and time. Constancy of the speed of light the speed of light in a vacuum is a constant1 in all inertial reference frames. Norton, einsteins special theory of relativity and the. It can lead to unexpected behavior in any quantity that requires synchronized clocks for its measurement. Describe how simultaneity is a relative concept for observers in different inertial frames in relative motion. Simultaneity and clock synchronization reza mansouri and roman u. In physics the lorentzeinstein transformations let are the algebra of special relativity. A theory that neglecting the effects of gravity reconciles the principle of relativity with the observation that the speed of light is constant in all frames of reference.
In physics, the relativity of simultaneity is the concept that distant simultaneity whether two. With a proper understanding of simultaneity and of other temporal concepts, distant simultaneity in special relativity can be shown to be observerindependent for a significant set of events. The speed of light is the same to all observers, irrespective of their motion. If one reference frame assigns precisely the same time to two events that are at different points in space, a reference frame that is moving relative to the first will generally assign different. How to do calculation in relativity of simultaneity. The relativity of simultaneity is one of the central results of the special theory of relativity. Before explaining how the godseye view resolves the impasse of theoretical physics and foundations of physics created by the antseye view, the book presents a detailed argument for the block universe. The special theory of relativity and its applications to. The special theory of relativity is the theory credited to and detailedproposed by albert einstein in his third 1905 paper titled \on the electrodynamics of moving bodies.
As you can guess from the equations for the lorentz transformation, the concept of time becomes a relative concept since we no longer have the simple relation tt. Simultaneity by slow clock transport in the special theory. Problem 1 special theory of relativity an advanced spacecraft travels past earth and mars in a straight line at speed v 0. In 1905 albert einstein developed the theory of special relativity. Special relativity and its experimental foundation advanced. Einsteins rethinking resulted in the special theory of relativity that states that the velocity dependence of simultaneity is a consequence of the relativity. In this problem we will carry out two versions of a. Sp 2 contd a the effective time of fall for a photon is the velocity of the fall is the maximum acceleration acting for this effective time. The relativity of simultaneity is among the key results of special relativity and one that is particularly dif. We could send signals between the clocks if we could send signals at infinite speed, then there would be no problem simultaneity in special relativity continued but there are no such signals which is where the galilean transformation goes wrong from a practical perspective, we could use light signals, which propagate at the. He holds degrees in physics, mathematics, and the history of science, has published a book and a ted ed video on young einstein. Knowing algebra the parent could solve the problem in two lines, but he may have serious problems explaining it in simple but.
Absolute distant simultaneity in special relativity. A number of these authors seem to conclude that relativity poses no special problems for the atheory. Accordingly, the main thread of chapter 2 shows how the relativity of simultaneity resolves the paradoxes associated with time dilation and length contraction that result from special. I believe that the problem of how einstein discovered the special theory of. The analysis of relativistic rotation has evolved from a theoretical problem to a practical one in recent years as clock technology has grown ever. Conceptual problems on introductory special relativity. Due to his work in the area of quantum mechanics and understanding waveparticle duality of the properties of light, einstein was dissatis ed with the growing. According to einsteins special theory of relativity, it is impossible to say in an.
Student understanding of time in special relativity. Relative simultaneity predicted by special relativity is shown to be false. It is logically wrong to state that the experiments mentioned in the other answers prove the relativity of simultaneity, since there are alternative theories to special relativity in agreement with all experiments to date in which absolute simultaneity is preserved. No student seemed to have had difficulty neglecting the vertical dimension. Conventionality of simultaneity stanford encyclopedia of. Given that the unrestricted notion of existence depends on the notion of simultaneity, there are some problems in conciliating presentism with the special theory of relativity str, according to which the notion of. In other words perhaps all matter is always, constantly, doing something some where. Relativity of light the relativity of light is a treatise which describes, explains, analyses, scrutinizes, and falsifies albert einsteins special theory of relativity, and. How to do calculation in relativity of simultaneity physics. Special relativity practice problems a textbook based on this website is now available from cambridge university press.
Principle of relativity a229004 3 a229004 principle of relativity 5 problem. For these reasons, many have sought to understand how einstein worked his magic and came to special relativity. An ether theory is constructed that maintains absolute simultaneity and is kinematically equivalent to special relativity. There is one more than would suffice for einsteins description of relativity of simultaneity, but this will help our analysis. Special relativity and its experimental foundation. All equations and effects of special relativity can be derived from this rotational symmetry the poincare group of minkowski spacetime. Mass and energy relativistic addition of velocities. Simultaneity in newtonian mechanics and special relativity. In section 1, i present the standard argument raised against this compatibility. Synchronization by the einstein procedure and by slow clock transport turn out to be equivalent if and only if the time dilatation factor is given by the einstein result 1. Because the rod is moving in frame s, it is necessary to measure the coordinates x1 and x2 at the same time then from the inverse lorentz transformation with t1 t2, the length of the rod l. In general the second observer traces out a worldline in the spacetime of the first observer described by t x v, and the set of simultaneous.
We turn now to three paradoxes of special relativity. The distance is measured in the xed frame of reference, in which the sun, earth, and mars are at rest. Special relativity time dilation length contraction along the direction of motion space and time are relative relativity of simultaneity velocities are relative, except for that of light, and add up in such a way that they never exceed the velocity of light. Discovering the relativity of simultaneity how did einstein take the. Jun 20, 2001 in keeping with standard practice in onedimensional problems on special relativity, students were told in all questions that all motions were to be considered as occurring along a single line in space. Problems in the electrodynamics of moving bodies that led him to it. Special relativity is an extremely counterintuitive subject, and in this chapter we will see how its bizarre. The wellknown trainembankment thought experiment fails to demonstrate the phenomenon and global simultaneity as. It is not reasonable to expect that students even those facile with mathematical formalism. A demonstration of how, according to special relativity, different observers will disagree on what events happen at the same time. Alice throws a ball in a train time dilation, proper time, relativity of simultaneity, invariance of coincidences it all hangs together by a tightknit logic. According to einsteins special theory of relativity, it is impossible to say in an absolute sense that two distinct events occur at the same time if those events are separated in space. Pdf is the relativity of simultaneity a temporal illusion.
35 13 936 420 1085 802 1419 481 1458 704 605 431 1315 936 1524 1168 420 979 739 661 1049 1365 8 1269 219 479 205 779 1058 780 141 1567 1228 1349 873